Okay, I never thought I’d write an article about critical thinking. Ugh.
Critical thinking is unsexy because it’s in university syllabuses.
Rule of thumb: if your high school teachers preached it to you 15 years ago (don’t lie and tell me you understood WTF pemikiran kritis dan kreatif was), and your university books have a chapter on it — it’s definitely not sexy. Add extra “uncool” points for appearing on the World Economic Forum 21st-Century Skills List.
(For something on the other end of the cool spectrum, see Bitcoin: nobody fully understands it, a small group of people are getting rich AF, and it’s disrupting millennia-old beliefs on money. Cue Meme: “VCs and Bankers hate him!”)
But actually, critical thinking is critical to leading a good life. If only they had called it something like:
“How to spot bullshit, and make decisions that will drastically improve your life.”
Then maybe they’d have our attention. Because that’s what really critical thinking is. And today, we’ll explore why it’s so important and how to use it in our lives.
Why Critical Thinking? Because There’s a Lot of BS Out There
Here’s an example of what critical thinking is not. This might be familiar if you have annoying relatives in your WhatsApp groups:
- Sally, our heroine sees 2000s-era video of three people (Bonus points if they’re Asian) in doctor’s coats talking about how drinking lime water makes you slim, increases your IQ, and makes you live forever.
- Sally immediately sends video to the five WhatsApp groups she’s in. “Good sharing for health.”
- Sally starts putting lime into every bit of water within one square kilometer of her kitchen sink. We’re unsure about the results of the “slimming” water, but it’s certainly not very obvious.
No, this isn’t a rant against lime water. Heck, I love drinking lime juice too (with no sugar please, because that stuff will kill you). It’s not even a rant against Aunt Sally, because I know at least she has good intentions.
But this is a rant against the filters we set for ourselves on the information we allow in our lives. There’s a lot of “information” out there in the world, but unlike good ol’ Aunt Sally — many sources don’t have good intentions.
Maybe they’re trying to sell you something. Maybe they’re pushing a political agenda. Maybe they’re trying to take over the world by stimulating lime-juice-triggered brain cells that will now obey the Jewish Illuminati’s commands (Yes, if you don’t practice critical thinking, you start to believe all kinds of crazy conspiracy theories.)
The mainstream media has many creative names: fake news, alternative facts, opinions — but let’s call it out for what it is. Bullshit.
The world is full of it, but maybe critical thinking can save us.
We’re All Very Susceptible to BS
But you say, “Stop being an intellectual snob, Aaron. You think you’re so smart, but I drank lime water for three months — then I lost 0.9 kg and it cured my cough! Who are you to call it bullshit!?”
In this era of fake news — how do we know what’s right and wrong? How can I tell with absolute certainty that drinking lime water will not make you live forever?
It actually starts with a very counter-intuitive step. To become a good bullshit detector (a.k.a. critical thinker), we first need to realize that we’re all naturally bad at thinking. Cue wise, deep voice:
To become a rational thinker, we must first realize we’re irrational.
Because ironically, most of what allows fake news to thrive originates within us. For example, some people refuse to vaccinate their babies. You and I probably think it’s ridiculous (because we’re exposed to science, but perhaps more importantly, most of our friends and families do vaccinate their babies).
But what if you lived in a small community where:
- Your local religious leader says immunization is against your holy book (authority bias)
- All your close friends don’t vaccinate their kids (bandwagon effect)
- They show anti-vaccination conspiracy videos at all social gatherings (illusory truth effect)
Would you be as willing to vaccinate your kids as you are today? Despite the overwhelming amount of science proving it — I know it’d still be difficult for me.
That’s just one example where cognitive biases affect our decisions. But the hard truth is, our biases (the demons that make us bad at thinking) are always with us; constantly screwing with our decision making. Can we ever be fully rational thinkers?
Unfortunately, no. But at least by recognizing our biases, we can start deliberately fighting to make our decisions better.
(Further reading: Here’s a great HBR article on strategies to overcome biases.)
Getting to Root Causes
But recognizing biases is just one aspect of becoming a critical thinker. Another important aspect is learning to question effectively, and discovering root causes.
For inspiration, let’s take everyone’s favorite modern-day hero: Elon Musk. Elon Musk is awesome because he’s a billionaire, he does crazy things like building electric cars and rockets, and he’s even the inspiration for Marvel’s Tony Stark character.
One of Elon Musk’s favorite thinking methods is something called First Principles. In his own words:
“First Principles is a … way of looking at the world. You boil things down to the most fundamental truths and say, ‘What are we sure is true?’ … and then reason up from there.”
– Elon Musk –
Not all of us are going to use First Principles to become great inventors like Mr. Musk. But we can all learn something from this process — asking questions until we get to the root of things. For example, here’s one of my favorite things to talk about: Should You Buy a New Car?
And my line of internal questioning might go something like this:
Should You Buy a New Car?
1. Why do you want to buy a new car?
Because I need a car to get to work.
2. Is it really true that you need a car to get to work? What about public transport, Grab, or even a motorcycle?
Motorcycles are dangerous. Grab is more expensive than owning a car. Public transport is just… troublesome.
3. So it’s not just about getting to work. It’s about getting to work in the safest and most convenient way, right? But is the inconvenience really worth the huge costs? Are you sure that’s your only motivation?
Of course it’s not just about getting to work; I want it to be safe and convenient too. Okay, if I’m being really honest, it’s also because I like owning new things, and having a nice car shows people I’ve “made it.”
4. Why do you need to show people that you’ve “made it”? What value does that bring to you?
Hmmm… I haven’t thought about that so deeply yet. But all the successful business people I know drive nice cars. And all the fabulous people on social media…
5. But you know that appearances on social media can be made up right? And how sure are you that the “successful” people you’re talking about aren’t shit-deep in debt because of their nice cars?
Go away — I don’t like talking to you.
Asking a series of basic questions can quickly make you sound like an asshole (so maybe use it sparingly with people — unless they’re asking you for advice?). But it’s a great internal process to help you find out root causes.
Everyone Has a Motive
Let’s move on to people now. Because similar to how every situation has a root cause, every person has a motive.
And if we think about it, apart from naturally-occurring things like the wind blowing — almost everything else is caused by people decisions. Which is in turn caused by their motives.
As James Altucher says,
“There’s always a good reason, and there’s always the real reason.”
Part of being a great critical thinker is learning to look for the real motivations behind what people do. For example…
- If your parents are nagging you twenty times a week to get married, is it because they don’t want you to grow old and die alone (highly likely), or is it because they like tiring wedding ceremonies (less likely).
- If your unit trust agent calls you weekly to have coffee, is it because she thinks you’re handsome, or is it because she gets a free holiday to Barcelona if she meets her sales target?
- If your manager keeps micro-managing your work, is it because he’s a bona fide asshole, or is it because you haven’t proven yourself worthy of his trust?
Of course, most of us aren’t mind-reading experts who can read people accurately. We’re normal people with biases. So even our evaluations of motives and root causes will be wrong sometimes. Maybe a lot of the time.
But like any other skill, the more we practice, the better we’ll get at it.
How to Deal With Large Volumes of Data
Have you ever felt overwhelmed by the huge amount of information you’re bombarded with every day? I know I have. And I’m a blogger — so I’m actually supposed to be good at managing large amounts of data.
So what do I do if I need to make a decision, but am feeling overwhelmed by a mountain of data?
The quickest way would be to fall back to trust.
Like if you asked me quickly — what news sources do I trust? The New York Times, Washington Post and BBC would be on that list. This isn’t to say they’re perfect, but if I have only five minutes to check, and it’s on the Washington Post — I have enough faith in their reputation, standards and ethics.
But trust is a dangerous thing, especially if it’s just from one source. If you have a little more time, a process called Triangulation is more useful.
In triangulation, we use multiple sources to check on the same thing. And we use our knowledge on “trusted sources” to narrow it down. For example:
- If you search for “Money Game,” and only one of the Top 30 (I usually go through the first 3 pages of Google) results supports Money Games. And it’s an anonymous blog full of bombastic promises, over-smiley men in suits, and dodgy advertisements — you probably can’t trust it.
- If you search for “Is Bitcoin a scam” and 30 publications/newspapers including CNN, Forbes, CNBC (and reputable blogs like mr-stingy!) have covered it — you can probably be more confident.
Interestingly, we’re really good at finding data to support what we already believe (confirmation bias). So it’s important to also look for data that goes against what we already believe. To try and understand all sides of an argument.
I realize the above is really just common sense. But in our age of lazy thinking and fake information, common sense apparently isn’t that common anymore.
You Eventually Have to Move
Up to this point, we’ve spoken a lot about mental stuff: asking questions, looking for motives, and sorting through data. I know, it’s unsexy.
So here’s the final part: taking action. Because what good is it if you have the greatest strategies in the world, but don’t do anything with it? That would just make you a skilled mental masturbator. Don’t let trying to make a good decision paralyze you from making any decision at all.
I write this from personal experience. I’ve always been a very analytical and calculated decision-maker. But that also means I’m not spontaneous and have often missed out great opportunities — because I’m so afraid to make wrong decisions.
Don’t be like me. Because apart from sorting through all the data the world gives us — you need personal experience too. And you only get that by making decisions, taking action, and facing the consequences. Everything you critically thought out was just theory — now test it out and see what happens?
Then reflect on your experiences and check if you need to modify your thinking. Yes, it’s really a never-ending process of thinking — action — feedback. And done right, it can incrementally improve your life.
An iPhone engineer might call it an improvement cycle.
I’d like to think it’s the circle of life.
– – –
Further reading: James Clear’s Common Mental Errors and Mental Models. College Info Geek. The Critical Thinking Community. Wise Bread.
Pics from Pexels, Pexels, Pexels and Pexels.
Hi Aaron ,
Thanks for posting this article , it has help me tremendously ,
i have try applied “First Principle ” mentioned in this post to some some really tough problem
in my work place , then things just get clearer once we get into the fundamentals and move up from there.
Thank you so much, I’m so happy to hear it’s been helpful!
“So it’s important to also look for data that goes against what we already believe. To try and understand all sides of an argument.”
I truly believe this is quite impossible because it’s against your personal belief and value. How many of us really want to be in an uncomfortable zone?
Hello Vincent, I believe this is very possible. Just because it goes against our beliefs and values doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to learn about it. Just because it’s uncomfortable doesn’t mean we shouldn’t face it. Growth by nature is uncomfortable…
bout the car one:
I only need one answer to defeat all the rational thinking:
Cause It make me happpy and I only live once!
*Grab a 6 speed manual, rear wheel drive sport car with natural aspirated engine and 300hp, slam on the throttle and went to the horizon*
Not a car enthusiast so I can’t feel you there man. 😛
hi Aaron Tang
You just wrote an excellent articles reflect my characters.
I love to be a critical thinker all the times. But as you said beautifully, too critical thinking can caused miss opportunity to do great things.
In life , we need to have a happy and healthy mindset to do rational things rather irrational things.
I try reflect what I have say orally or written to someone. How we perceive those messages we read maybe different for different people. In today world, we wasted so much time to google things or facts to prove somethings that are obvious. Example , why the sky is blue and why the ocean is blue? These 2 questions were asked by 5 or 8 years old kids. Adults or young people treat internet as “God of information” and they seek answers online. We can buy almost anything online, including your life partner. But are we happy to live a meaningful life without those IT gadgets or internet stuff to make our life only appear in the virtual world.
I think in a near future, human become a slave to a AI computer because we depend so much things from machines, robots and computers. Our critical thinking abilities will be disappeared and extinct forever. If you really watched the Planet of the Apes movies, the apes become more intelligent than human. That fact will become a reality very soon. Another example I can think of is if the critical service providers, like the Airport or airlines or online banking went off line on the internet, can we do our jobs on a manual mode rather than computer mode?
I think eventually computers might become smarter than humans. Several thought leaders including people like Elon Musk have already written about it. The world is changing, but I think we need to do all we can to prepare ourselves for huge changes. And I guess we’ll just see what the future holds!
A very sensible topic. Most of us nowadays just roll over when told to without ever questioning. Thanks Aaron
Thanks Ram! Appreciate it lots…